EV Supply Chain Transformation: Embracing Sustainability through Electric Trucks

The automotive industry is embracing a pivotal shift towards electric vehicles (EVs), driven by the pressing need for sustainable transportation solutions. This transformation has sparked a surge in demand for lithium-ion batteries and critical minerals essential for battery manufacturing, catalyzing a revolution within the EV supply chain.

As the adoption of EVs accelerates, addressing the challenges within the electric vehicle battery supply chain becomes paramount for both environmental consciousness and economic viability. From battery production and procurement to recycling strategies, this article delves into the multifaceted aspects of the EV supply chain transformation, exploring fuel cost savings, tax incentives, operational efficiencies, environmental impact, financial advantages, and real-world case studies of early adopters.

Fuel Cost Savings

One of the most significant advantages of adopting electric trucks is the substantial fuel cost savings compared to traditional diesel-powered vehicles. The average cost to charge an electric vehicle (EV) is $0.05 per mile, significantly lower than the $0.14 per mile for a typical gas-powered vehicle, leading to significant fuel cost savings. Electric trucks, particularly those in the Class 4-6 range, are rapidly replacing gasoline and diesel-fueled models due to their lower per-mile fuel costs, primarily driven by the higher efficiency of electric motors and the lower cost of electricity.

Quantifying the Savings

To illustrate the potential savings, consider the following scenario: a fleet of 25 heavy-duty trailer trucks switching from fossil fuels to electricity could save approximately $300,000 annually, equating to $0.26 per mile. Additionally, this transition would enable the fleet to generate Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) credits, potentially generating an additional $627,000 per year. The EV Fleet Savings Calculator tool can assist businesses and organizations in calculating the expenses associated with transitioning their fleets to electric vehicles, providing a comprehensive understanding of the potential cost savings.

Long-Term Cost Advantages

Studies have shown that electric cars and passenger trucks will save their owners thousands of dollars over the next decade compared to gas-powered vehicles. While electric vehicles currently have higher upfront purchase and insurance costs, these are more than offset by fuel and maintenance cost savings. In fact, all studied electric vehicles purchased this year are expected to have the same or lower total cost of ownership over their lifetime compared to gasoline vehicles. These cost savings are projected to increase as battery prices continue to decline and production scales up, with estimates suggesting lifetime cost savings of up to $18,440 for electric vehicle owners.

Tax Incentives and Subsidies

Federal and State Tax Credits

The federal government and many states offer significant tax credits and incentives to encourage the adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) and fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs). In 2023, individuals and businesses may qualify for a tax credit of up to $7,500 for purchasing a new, qualified plug-in EV or FCEV. However, the vehicle must meet specific requirements related to battery capacity, gross vehicle weight rating, final assembly location, critical mineral and battery component requirements, and Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price (MSRP).

The credit amount depends on when the vehicle is placed in service and whether it meets the critical mineral and battery component requirements. Buyers must file Form 8936 with their tax return to claim the credit, and the seller must provide a time-of-sale report.

1. Federal Tax Credits:
   • Get a tax credit of up to $7,500 for new vehicles purchased in or after 2023.
   • Get a credit of up to $4,000 for used vehicles purchased from a dealer for $25,000 or less, with the amount equaling 30% of the purchased price and a maximum credit of $4,000.
   • Get a tax credit of up to $7,500 for new vehicles purchased before 2023, with the amount varying based on battery capacity and manufacturer phase-out.
2. State Tax Credits and Incentives:
   • Many states, such as Maryland, offer additional tax credits, rebates, and incentives for EV and FCEV purchases, charging station installations, and alternative fuel vehicle grants.
   • Maryland State Incentives include an EV and FCEV Tax Credit up to $3,000, EV Charging Station Rebates up to $5,000, EV HOV Lane Permit, EV Emissions Inspection Exemption, and Alternative Fuel Vehicle Grants up to $150,000.

Other Incentives and Subsidies

In addition to tax credits, various incentives and subsidies are available to further reduce the cost of EVs and charging infrastructure:

1. Commercial EV and FCEV Tax Credit: 15% of the purchase price for plug-in hybrids, 30% for EVs and FCEVs, up to $7,500 for under 14,000 lbs and $40,000 for over 14,000 lbs.
2. Alternative Fuel Vehicle Refueling Property Credit: 6% of depreciable costs up to $100,000 per item, or 30% up to $100,000 if it meets prevailing wage and apprenticeship requirements.
3. Tax credits are available that could save up to 30% off the cost of installing EV charging infrastructure, if the home, business, or facility is in an eligible location.
4. Many governments offer incentives like tax rebates, exemptions, and credits to help offset the higher upfront costs of EVs.
5. Utility companies also provide incentives such as EV Charging Rate Reductions, Rebates, and Multifamily EV Charging Station Rebates up to $20,000.

These tax incentives and subsidies aim to make EVs and FCEVs more affordable for individuals and businesses, promoting the adoption of sustainable transportation solutions and reducing the environmental impact of traditional fossil fuel-powered vehicles.

Maintenance and Operational Efficiency

Reduced Maintenance Requirements

Electric trucks have the potential for significantly less maintenance compared to diesel trucks, as they eliminate the need for oil changes, coolant leaks, and aftertreatment system maintenance. However, the transition to electric trucks introduces new maintenance requirements, such as dealing with multiple electric motors, torque converters, and battery systems. Companies like Penske Truck Leasing, an early adopter of electric trucks, have found that servicing these vehicles requires a “whole different level of service technician” – one trained in high-voltage troubleshooting rather than traditional diesel maintenance. Penske is implementing a comprehensive training program to certify technicians at locations receiving electric trucks, including safety equipment, special tooling, and high-voltage knowledge.

Predictive Maintenance and Data Analytics

Electric trucks are equipped with advanced sensors and telematics that generate real-time data, enabling predictive maintenance. Remote diagnostics and over-the-air (OTA) updates allow manufacturers to remotely diagnose issues and seamlessly enhance software/firmware. Maintenance is evolving from a reactive “break-fix” model to a proactive, predictive approach enabled by data analytics. Continuous monitoring of component health through IoT sensors prevents unexpected breakdowns and optimizes total cost of ownership (TCO). Manufacturers and service providers can transition to offering “service-as-a-solution” (SaaS) packages, including predictive maintenance, software updates, and performance optimization services.

Operational Efficiency and Maintenance Savings

1. Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER): The EER of battery-electric trucks and buses compared to conventional diesel vehicles is significantly higher, especially at lower average speeds. The EER is about 3.5 at highway speeds and 5 to 7 times more efficient than diesel vehicles when operated at lower speeds where idling and coasting losses are highest.
2. Maintenance Costs:
   • Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) and hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs) have maintenance requirements similar to conventional vehicles, as they have internal combustion engines.
   • All-electric vehicles typically require less maintenance than conventional vehicles because they have fewer fluids, less brake wear due to regenerative braking, and far fewer moving parts.
   • The advanced batteries used in electric vehicles have a limited number of charging cycles (cycle life), and replacement batteries outside the warranty period are expected to be a significant expense.
3. Operational Advantages:
   • EVs have fewer moving parts, so there is less maintenance required, helping to lower overall maintenance expenses.
   • Electric trucks offer increased uptime, more predictable maintenance costs, and long-term savings compared to diesel trucks.
   • EVs have lower maintenance and operational costs due to simpler mechanical systems requiring less regular upkeep, such as no need for costly oil changes.
   • The quiet operation of electric trucks enables businesses to operate outside typical hours, enhancing efficiency and service delivery.
   • Battery electric vehicles typically require less maintenance compared to diesel-powered trucks due to fewer moving parts.

Environmental Impact and Brand Image

Corporate Social Responsibility and Brand Reputation

Switching to an electric fleet demonstrates corporate social responsibility and a commitment to sustainability, which is increasingly important to consumers. Adopting an electric vehicle fleet positions the company as a green and socially responsible brand that cares about the environment. This can lead to a positive brand reputation, stronger customer loyalty, and the ability to attract new environmentally-conscious customers. Showcasing innovation and forward-thinking by embracing sustainable transportation solutions can position the company as a leader in the industry. Providing electric vehicles for employees can enhance employee satisfaction, morale, and retention, further improving the company’s overall image.

Competitive Advantage and Environmental Impact

Using electric vehicles can show your company’s commitment to reducing energy consumption and contributing to a cleaner, more sustainable environment. Electric vehicles can send a powerful message to customers, as they arrive silently, stand out, and incorporate electric vehicle messaging. Switching to an electric vehicle fleet demonstrates that your company is taking its Corporate Social Responsibility seriously. Sustainability statements in tenders are becoming more common, and using electric vehicles can give your company a competitive edge. In the haulage industry, green procurement rules often include scoring for energy efficiency and environmental impacts, which electric vehicles can help address.

Emissions and Environmental Considerations

1. Emissions Reduction: Electric vehicles have a lower carbon footprint compared to traditional internal combustion engine vehicles, which can positively impact the environment. Reducing emissions associated with fleet transport can make a positive impact on climate change.
2. Vehicle Size and Emissions: Larger electric vehicles like electric pickup trucks tend to have higher emissions per mile compared to smaller electric vehicles, due to the need for larger batteries and more electricity to charge them. The emissions savings from driving an electric pickup truck like the Ford F-150 Lightning compared to a gas-powered F-150 can be around 50% less greenhouse gas emissions per mile. However, the largest electric vehicles can have similar life cycle emissions as some smaller gas-powered cars, negating some of the environmental benefits.
3. Safety Considerations: Heavier electric vehicles like the Hummer EV and F-150 Lightning can be more dangerous in crashes for other drivers, pedestrians, cyclists, and wheelchair users due to their increased weight and size.
4. Heavy-Duty Truck Emissions: Heavy-duty trucks are the fastest-growing source of climate pollution in the U.S., emitting nearly a quarter of the climate pollution from transportation. Heavy-duty trucks are responsible for 45% of the nitrogen oxide (NOx) pollution and 57% of the fine particulate (PM 2.5) pollution in the U.S., which are linked to premature death and chronic illnesses. These pollution impacts disproportionately affect low-income and BIPOC communities located near major roadways and freight hubs.

Long-Term Financial Advantages

Higher Upfront Costs, Significant Long-Term Savings

While electric vehicles (EVs), including electric trucks, have higher upfront costs compared to traditional combustion vehicles, they offer significant long-term cost savings. As EV technology continues to advance and manufacturing processes become more efficient, the upfront costs are expected to become more affordable in the coming years. The long-term cost savings and environmental benefits of EVs can more than offset the higher initial investment, making them a financially savvy option for supply chain operations.

Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) Advantages

Despite the higher initial purchase price, the total cost of ownership (TCO) often favors electric trucks due to lower operating and maintenance costs. Real-world examples from companies like UPS, FedEx, DHL, PepsiCo, and Ryder System demonstrate significant fuel and maintenance cost savings from transitioning to electric trucks. Projected savings and return on investment (ROI) analysis over a five-year period show that the ROI becomes significantly positive by the fifth year, driven by the cumulative effect of annual operating savings and increased resale value.

Adoption Trends and Cost Parity

1. Light-duty and medium-duty electric truck adoption could surpass passenger EV sales by 2030 in some markets due to TCO advantages.
2. Heavy-duty electric trucks will see slower adoption due to higher battery costs, but could reach 15-34% sales penetration by 2030 in an ‘early adoption’ scenario.
3. The optimal daily driving distance for electric trucks to achieve TCO parity is around 200 km.
4. Electric city buses could achieve TCO parity as early as 2023-2025.
5. Light-duty urban applications can achieve TCO parity today with some modifications to the use case.
6. Regulations around emissions and urban access will be a key driver of electric truck adoption, especially in China, Europe, and some U.S. cities.

Case Studies: Early Adopters on EV supply chain

Adoption and Pricing

The transition to electric trucks is underway, with major companies leading the charge as early adopters. In 2020, the price range for diesel-powered tractors was between $110,000 and $125,000, indicating a total showroom value of ~$445 billion for all heavy-duty trucks. Tesla’s electric Freightliner trucks, on the other hand, are priced at $150,000 (for a range of 300 miles) and $200,000 (for a range of 500 miles). Replacing all 3.8 million Class 8 trucks at a starting price of $150,000 per unit would amount to an estimated cost of ~$570 billion. Currently, electric trucks only account for 4% of annual truck sales based on recent estimates.

Charging Infrastructure Developments

1. Charging infrastructure is a major challenge, but may not be as critical as for passenger cars due to more predictable driving patterns.
2. Since 2021, almost $22 billion in investments in electric vehicle chargers have been announced, which will deploy more than 800,000 new charging ports by 2030.
3. Over the course of this decade, investments announced since the passage of the Inflation Reduction Act will result in the deployment of almost five times as many chargers as we have now.
4. The U.S. will have 70% of all the public chargers it needs by 2030 from just existing and already-announced deployment, and more than 100% of what is needed when including unawarded grants and other less specific commitments.

Industry Initiatives

Major companies like Walmart, General Motors, Cumberland Farms, Kohl’s, Kroger, Shell, Subway, Target, and Wawa have announced major electric charger deployments. Concrete plans to deploy EV charging stations have been announced by various stakeholders, including federal/state governments, retailers, automakers, toll road operators, utilities, truck stop operators, service stations, and fleet owners. Since 2021, almost $22 billion in investments have been announced for deploying over 800,000 new EV charging ports by 2030. By 2030, the U.S. will have 70% of all the public EV chargers it needs from existing and already announced deployments.

FAQs